Almost back to full health, 51黑料 City SC searches for a complete game as elimination nears
It鈥檚 been six months since the Major League Soccer season started, dozens and dozens of practices have been held, 24 games have been played, two coaches have been used, and still 51黑料 City SC is in search of a complete game, one where both the offense and defense perform at a high level for the full 90 minutes.
鈥淓very game we have the feeling we had a good game,鈥 said midfielder Celio Pompeu, 鈥渙r we play the first half very good, or sometimes we play the second half very good. But we need to play 90 minutes. The football match is 90 minutes. Like Minnesota, we were playing very good in the first half, one of the best games we had. And then the second half started little slow, two mistakes, two PKs, and we lost.鈥
鈥淲e need to go forward,鈥 said center back Timo Baumgartl, 鈥渂ecause you can see how we can play. That鈥檚 the thing which is optimistic for me to see how we can play, but it鈥檚 not 90 minutes, and that鈥檚 the thing.鈥
51黑料 City SC defender Timo Baumgartl takes a seat on the ground after the final whistle to end a match against Minnesota United at Energizer Park on Saturday, July 26, 2025.
David Carson
The search comes back to Energizer Park on Saturday when City SC faces Nashville, the third-place team in the Eastern Conference. City SC, meanwhile, sits in 14th place in the Western Conference, and while the team talks about holding out hopes for the playoffs until the math says they can鈥檛, its biggest chase is to stay out of last place. City SC is two points up on the last-place Los Angeles Galaxy, meaning the team is just one bad weekend away from falling to the bottom.
For all the talk of the team鈥檚 improved play, the team has still lost five of its past six games.
鈥淲e鈥檙e getting closer every week,鈥 said interim coach David Critchley. 鈥淭hese guys are getting fitter, they鈥檙e getting sharper. So, I think we鈥檙e hopefully very close to it. Hopefully it鈥檚 this Saturday. We know we鈥檝e put together good spells in games, whether that鈥檚 a time spell, like a 45-minute, 60-minute (period), or we鈥檝e been really good on one side of the ball. Maybe not both. And that鈥檚 a collective right? If I say we鈥檙e good on the offensive side, I don鈥檛 just mean Klauss and the forwards. I mean, Roman (Burki), Timo, the defenders, that collectively we鈥檙e good on one side of the ball. So, the balance right now is the most important thing for this group. We want to put an entertaining attacking style of soccer out there for the fans and to win games, but sometimes you have to have a mindset of, how do you respond defensively as well, quickly? So that balance, I think, is what we are trying to figure out right now. We鈥檙e getting closer every week to it.鈥
There are 10 games remaining in the season, and that鈥檚 almost definitely not enough time. If City SC were to win out, it would get to 48 points; the last playoff team in the West last season had 47 points. If the conference ends up looking more like the East last season, where the last playoff team had 40 points, City SC needs to win eight of its last 10. But a reminder: it has won four games so far all season.
鈥淏ut we are, I think, on the right track,鈥 Baumgartl said, 鈥渁nd Critch leads us to the right track. And that鈥檚 the most important thing, to make these steps. At the end, football is a result game, so we need results, and that鈥檚 for the next 10 games.鈥
Critchley has acknowledged that he now needs to do get the defense to catch up with the offense. The defense started the season with four shutouts. It has one since.
鈥淲e made a big step in creating chances. That鈥檚 important for us,鈥 Baumgartl said. 鈥淣ow it鈥檚 about to (giving) less goals, trying to defend more as a team together, because I have the feeling after 60 minutes, it鈥檚 like the room is getting bigger, the spaces for the other teams getting bigger. And that鈥檚 important for us. If we have that feeling, OK, we need to stick together. We need to build another momentum. We try to get that momentum flipped, because we can see we can challenge every team, but not over 90 minutes for the moment. That鈥檚 the problem.鈥
City SC is as healthy as it has been all season, with forward Cedric Teuchert out with what Critchley termed 鈥渕uscle fatigue,鈥 joining backup center back Michael Wentzel as the only players out due to injury. The team will still be lacking as Chris Durkin (red card) and Conrad Wallem (yellow cards) sit out the game with suspensions.
The last 10 games may be the ones that show either how good this team could have been without the injuries or where it needs to improve.
鈥淚鈥檓 always an optimistic guy, so we have 10 games left,鈥 Baumgartl said. 鈥淭here鈥檚 still a potential chance to reach that ninth or eighth place. So that鈥檚 my goal for this season. Maybe it鈥檚 a little bit high this goal, but for me, it鈥檚 in my mind we want to have these 10 games. We want to have as many points as we can get, that鈥檚 the thing. It鈥檚 always good to have a healthy group, to get players back. It was a hell of a ride this season with a lot of injuries, so I think it鈥檚 always good to have these guys back in the team, back on the pitch, and we鈥檙e trying to build on something special, and we want to be a team who bounced back in the last 10 games.鈥
Joakim NIlsson pens a farewell to City SC and 51黑料: 'A journey with both challenges and growth'
Joakim Nilsson, who had his contract bought out by 51黑料 City SC on Wednesday, after three seasons in which he was hurt more than he was healthy, penned a farewell note to the fans that he posted on Instagram on Thursday, thanking the team and its fans for the memories.
鈥淎 journey with both challenges and growth,鈥 he wrote. 鈥淯nfortunately, I鈥檝e spent a large part of the time sidelined due to injury, and I truly wish I could have been available more for the team and the fans. I loved every minute I was able to give everything for the club and I always wore the City Red with pride. However, being unable to contribute on the field has been tough, but has also made me appreciate the game even more.
鈥淭o the best fans in MLS: Thank you for all the love and support, both for me personally and for the team. Your passion means more than you know. Please keep supporting the team as you鈥檙e always doing. Also to my teammates, coaches, physios, and everyone working in and around the club 鈥 thank you for all the memories.
鈥淣ow, I鈥檓 looking forward to the next chapter, motivated and excited.
鈥淭hank you for everything.鈥
Nilsson, 31, was one of the first signings by the team and with his experience in both the Germany Bundesliga and internationally with Sweden was expected to be a guiding force for a young team. But he played in only 33 MLS games out of 88 in his 2 1/2 seasons with the club and had played in only six games in 2025, though teammates still singled him out for his leadership and counsel. As the team signed other center backs because of the ongoing uncertainty about Nilsson鈥檚 availability, it became increasingly apparent that even if he was healthy to play again in 2025聽鈥 City SC has 10 games remaining聽鈥 it would be tough to fit him into the lineup. Nilsson鈥檚 contract ran through the end of the 2026 season.
鈥淗e put everything into it,鈥 said interim coach David Critchley, who never had a healthy Nilsson since taking over on May 27, 鈥渆ven though he had a difficult time with the injuries and what happened in his career, but he showed up every day and he was a professional and he tried to find ways to help these guys, even if he wasn鈥檛 involved. So we thank him first and foremost. These guys have been really supportive of him and had a little bit of sympathy with the situation as well. It鈥檚 always a tough one when you lose a player that鈥檚 so connected to the locker room. But unfortunately, that鈥檚 some of the brutalness of professional sports.鈥
Critchley said it was unlikely that Nilsson would have played again this season.
鈥淚t was a decision that I think that himself and the club made and for all parties,鈥 Critchley said, 鈥渏ust for the health of him. I always think about it for these athletes as well, when they are going through so much pain as an injury, they need to be thinking about fatherhood and how they鈥檙e going to be in their 30s, 40s and 50s. So I think it was the right decision for both parties.鈥
51黑料 City SC coach David Critchley discusses preparation for Saturday's game against Nashville SC. Video edited by Beth O'Malley
51黑料 City SC coach discusses preparation for game against Nashville
Time of transition for 51黑料 City SC: STL Soccer Talk
Time of transition for 51黑料 City SC
51黑料 City SC beat writer Tom Timmermann and co-host Beth O'Malley say goodbye to center back Joakim Nilsson, whose time in 51黑料 was curtailed by just plain bad luck with injuries. Meanwhile, as the team's injury list shrinks, the internal competition for playing time, and continued employment, picks up.
51黑料
51黑料 City SC beat writer Tom Timmermann and co-host Beth O'Malley say goodbye to center back Joakim Nilsson, whose time in 51黑料 was curtailed by just plain bad luck with injuries. Meanwhile, as the team's injury list shrinks, the internal competition for playing time, and continued employment, picks up.
Cedric Teuchert ready to make his case for getting his starting spot back with 51黑料 City SC
One of the things 51黑料 City SC likes about the signing of Sangbin Jeong is the competition it creates at the forward position, where there now is not enough playing time to accommodate everyone.
Cedric Teuchert is painfully aware of that.
The arrival of Jeong, who has been in the starting lineup in each of his first two games with the club, means someone is coming out, and that player has been Teuchert. Teuchert was tied for the team lead in goals last season with five, and he did it in 10 games while the players he was tied with, Klauss and Eduard Lowen did it in 27 and 23 games respectively.
Against Minnesota, Jeong鈥檚 first game, Teuchert came off the bench and played 12 minutes, the fewest he鈥檚 played when healthy since joining the team. Against Aston Villa, he came on with the second wave of players at halftime. It was then that he scored the team鈥檚 only goal, his first since May 14 after 10 games without one.
鈥淚 was not happy to start on the bench against Minnesota,鈥 Teuchert said. 鈥淚 was not happy playing not that many minutes, and I tried to show the coach that I鈥檓 here and so it goes and help the team.鈥
The problem for Teuchert will be that with the team鈥檚 heavy investment in Jeong, and need to assimilate him into the team, he鈥檚 going to get playing time. Now, the team has an attacking corps that includes Klauss, Marcel Hartel, Celio Pompeu, Simon Becher and Xande Silva. The crunch has already hit Silva, who hasn鈥檛 played in the past two games, though interim coach David Critchley said not to read too much into that.
鈥淚t鈥檚 always good if you have more numbers in the team so nobody can sleep,鈥 Teuchert said. 鈥淚 mean, it鈥檚 good for every team to have this. The games in training, I give my best to go back in the starting 11 with some good sessions, scoring some goals in the training sessions, in the game (Wednesday). I want to keep the decision hard for the coaches, and I want to start. It鈥檚 my place there.鈥
Teuchert admits this season has had its frustrations.
鈥淚 think every striker is the same,鈥 he said. 鈥淚f you go a couple weeks with no goal, and you score again, it鈥檚 like stones from the body and it feels really good. I think it was a good, good finish against a good team. So I鈥檓 very happy.鈥
In Teuchert鈥檚 case, it was more than a couple of weeks. He scored the team鈥檚 first goal of the season, but he didn鈥檛 do a lot to get it, jumping on a misplayed corner kick by the Los Angeles Galaxy and putting the ball into an open net from a few feet out. His most recent goal prior to Aston Villa was a shot by Tomas Ostrak that caromed off his foot as he was trying to get out of the way and bounced into the net. Only his goal against LAFC on April 27 showed the touch he showed last season.
鈥淓very goal is good for me now,鈥 he said, 鈥渂ut I hope I can keep going against Nashville.鈥
鈥淚t鈥檒l do a lot,鈥 Critchley said. 鈥淚鈥檝e had a couple of individual meetings with Cedric. He鈥檚 been frustrated in himself that he鈥檚 not been scoring goals. He had a really good week. You go back to the Minnesota game, we start Sangbin, I think he feels that he has to have a good week to challenge Sangbin and challenge to get back on the starting 11. And (prior to Aston Villa) he had three or four good days on the training field. So to see him get rewarded with a goal was very good. So that鈥檚 the challenge I give him. That鈥檚 the challenge I give all the guys that aren鈥檛 in the starting 11, is make my job as hard as possible. And he鈥檚 gone and done that. So I鈥檓 happy that he鈥檚 doing that for me.鈥
Teuchert made his debut with City SC just over a year ago, on July 20, 2024. He scored his first goal a week later, in a Leagues Cup match against Dallas. It was the first of seven goals in 10 days for him.
He鈥檚 enjoyed his first year in America, as has his wife and his two children, one 4 1/2, the other 1 1/2.
鈥淚 think it鈥檚 a good year,鈥 he said. 鈥淚鈥檓 happy that I鈥檓 here. Of course, the last season when I was here was for me, personally, good, for the team it was good. And I mean, everybody can see it this season, we struggle. We struggle that we don鈥檛 get the points that we want. So ups and downs, but I think it鈥檚 normal in football, but we have to look forward and get these points.
鈥淚t鈥檚 perfect for me. My family is perfect. My wife, the kids feel good. I feel good. It鈥檚 a great team, great facility, great stadium. So we have everything we need to have a good life.鈥
Nothing would make it better than scoring more goals.
Nilsson bought out
City SC has bought out the contract of defender Joakim Nilsson, who was viewed as a foundational player for the club but who because of injuries seldom got on the field.
The move opened a senior roster spot for City SC, and his salary will not count against the club鈥檚 salary cap for 2025.
Nilsson appeared in only 33 of 88 MLS games for City SC over 2 1/2 seasons, mostly because of knee and hamstring issues. This season, he played in just six games, starting two. His last appearance was on April 5, when he started and came out after 26 minutes with an injury against Sporting Kansas City.
鈥淛oakim has been a true professional throughout his time in 51黑料,鈥 said sporting director Lutz Pfannenstiel in a statement released by the club. 鈥淯nfortunately, injuries prevented him from contributing as much as he and the club would have liked. We thank him for his commitment both on and off the field and wish him and his family all the best moving forward.鈥
Nilsson was the fifth player signed by City SC, on June 1, 2022, a veteran player who had been with the Swedish national team who was coming off three seasons in Germany and would be a defensive anchor for the team and make up part of the team鈥檚 spine. But he injured his knee shortly after signing while playing for the Swedish national team. The team hoped rest would get him back in shape for the inaugural season in 2023, but it didn鈥檛. Instead, he had surgery, which kept him out until Aug. 20 of that first season. He appeared in only eight regular-season games, plus one playoff game, that season.
He had surgery again after the 2023 season to clean up his knee but was able to play in 14 of the team鈥檚 first 17 games of 2024, though a rib injury suffered in practice in a collision with Nokkvi Thorisson kept him out of three and sharply limited his time in three others. He then missed 16 of 17 games with a hamstring injury and returned to play in the final four games of the season. He even got his wisdom teeth removed in hopes it would help his hamstrings.
鈥淚 just want the joy back,鈥 he said late in the season.
He did have his one shining moment with the team that season, scoring on a spectacular bicycle kick against the Los Angeles Galaxy.
鈥淢y first and my last,鈥 he said that night. 鈥淥ne hundred percent joy.鈥
He was looking forward to this season 鈥 鈥淚鈥檓 healthy, I鈥檓 back and I鈥檓 ready to go,鈥 he told the Post-Dispatch during training camp, after his first offseason without surgery since he joined the club 鈥 but he was on the receiving end of a hard tackle in the final preseason game and hurt his knee again, which led to the end of his time in 51黑料.
Teams are allowed to buy out two players鈥 contracts per season but have to do it before the close of the secondary buyout window, which comes on Aug. 21 this year. Nilsson鈥檚 contract had one more year on it after this one, with the club holding an option for the 2027 season.
Aston Villa coach Unai Emery and 51黑料 City SC interim coach David Critchley discuss the team's friendly match on Wednesday, July 30, 2025. Video by Beth O'Malley
51黑料 City SC buys out contract of injury-plagued center back Joakim Nilsson
51黑料 City SC has bought out the contract of defender Joakim Nilsson, who was viewed as a foundational player for the club but who because of injuries seldom got on the field.
The move opened a senior roster spot for City SC, and his salary will not count against the club鈥檚 salary cap for 2025.
Nilsson appeared in only 33 of 88 MLS games for City SC over 2 1/2 seasons, mostly because of knee and hamstring issues. This season, he played in just six games, starting two. His last appearance was on April 5, when he started and came out after 26 minutes with an injury against Sporting Kansas City.
鈥淛oakim has been a true professional throughout his time in 51黑料,鈥 said sporting director Lutz Pfannenstiel in a statement released by the club. 鈥淯nfortunately, injuries prevented him from contributing as much as he and the club would have liked. We thank him for his commitment both on and off the field and wish him and his family all the best moving forward.鈥
Nilsson was the fifth player signed by City SC, on June 1, 2022, a veteran player who had been with the Swedish national team who was coming off three seasons in Germany and would be a defensive anchor for the team and make up part of the team's spine. But he injured his knee shortly after signing while playing for the Swedish national team. The team hoped rest would get him back in shape for the inaugural season in 2023, but it didn鈥檛. Instead, he had surgery, which kept him out until Aug. 20 of that first season. He appeared in only eight regular-season games, plus one playoff game, that season.
He had surgery again after the 2023 season to clean up his knee but was able to play in 14 of the team鈥檚 first 17 games of 2024, though a rib injury suffered in practice in a collision with Nokkvi Thorisson kept him out of three and sharply limited his time in three others. He then missed 16 of 17 games with a hamstring injury and returned to play in the final four games of the season. He even got his wisdom teeth removed in hopes it would help his hamstrings.
鈥淚 just want the joy back,鈥 he said late in the season.
He did have his one shining moment with the team that season, scoring on a spectacular bicycle kick against the Los Angeles Galaxy.
"My first and my last," he said that night. "One hundred percent joy."
He was looking forward to this season聽鈥 鈥淚鈥檓 healthy, I鈥檓 back and I鈥檓 ready to go,鈥 he told the Post-Dispatch during training camp, after his first offseason without surgery since he joined the club聽鈥 but he was on the receiving end of a hard tackle in the final preseason game and hurt his knee again, which led to the end of his time in 51黑料.
Teams are allowed to buy out two players鈥 contracts per season but have to do it before the close of the secondary buyout window, which comes on Aug. 21 this year. Nilsson's contract had one more year on it after this one, with the club holding an option for the 2027 season.
Aston Villa coach Unai Emery and 51黑料 City SC interim coach David Critchley discuss the team's friendly match on Wednesday, July 30, 2025. Video by Beth O'Malley