Why Dogs May Offer More Fulfilling Relationships Than Most Humans
A new study from Hungarian researchers found that dog owners often experience a more fulfilling relationship with their pets than with most people, including friends and relatives. Published in Scientific Reports, the study shows dogs provide more support and fewer negative interactions than most human connections. Researchers found dogs ranked especially high in affection, reliability, and companionship, beating romantic partners, friends, and relatives in nearly every category except intimacy. So why are dogs such ideal companions? Experts point to three key factors: high companionship, low conflict, and clear caregiving roles. The dog-human bond is shaped by an unequal power dynamic; owners make the decisions, and dogs rarely challenge them. This reduces tension and conflict, common in human relationships. Participants were asked to evaluate relationships with their dogs and four people (closest relative, romantic partner, best friend, and child) using measures like nurturance and conflict. Results revealed that dog-owner relationships most closely resemble parent-child bonds, but with far fewer negative experiences. Importantly, people with strong human relationships also had strong bonds with their dogs, suggesting dogs complement, rather than replace, human connections. Having children slightly shifted perceptions; parents rated dogs lower in companionship, but most aspects remained unchanged. Ultimately, dogs provide steady emotional support without judgment or drama.